Heritage conservation, Chinese style: demolition

Beijing has announced plans to rebuild some of the gates in its long-lost imperial city wall: such is the way of heritage in China, where conservation often means demolition and putting up a replica.

The authorities are promising to restore the original appearance of the monumental Ming and Qing dynasty arches in the wall, which was demolished in the 1950s and stood where a ring road and metro line now run.

It is a hollow pledge. The landscape is so changed that even though China has excelled at copying for centuries, Beijingers have lined up to rail against the "fake antiquities" project.

A prime example is the Qianmen district, south of the Forbidden City. It was demolished during the giant renovation of the capital before the 2008 Olympics, then rebuilt as a historical theme park, complete with neon adverts for major international brands.

Since then, the practice of making a clean sweep of the past and rebuilding an inauthentic version, for instance with fake glazed roof tiles and kitsch hanging lanterns, has been dubbed "qianmenisation".

"It is an ignorant, stupid and greedy practice" said He Shuzhong, founder of Beijing's Centre for the Protection of Cultural Heritage.

"Ignorant because they do not know the meaning of cultural heritage; stupid, because they do not understand the old city's crucial role for society, and greedy because corruption permeates every step of the reconstruction."

Now Beijing's ancient Drum Tower and Nanluoguxiang areas have fallen victim to the bulldozers and are in the throes of "qianmenisation".

Others have already been transformed into "movie sets", as Hua Xinmin, activist and author of the book "I refuse to see my homeland disappear", puts it.

She is fighting an unequal battle against developers and local Communist officials who enrich themselves by destroying old neighbourhoods: they openly flout the law and forcibly evict residents, who often receive little in the way of compensation.

"It would be better to spend the money to preserve what is left instead of trying to remake what doesn't exist any more," she said, pointing out that two-thirds of Beijing's 3,000 old "hutongs", or alleys, have already vanished.

She is furious that the US weekly Time included Chen Lihua, a property magnate who destroyed her old Beijing neighbourhood, on its list of 2012's most influential people in the world.

The cycle of evictions followed by demolitions happens in every city in China.

In the the far west of the country, the Silk Road city of Kashgar is having its historic centre gutted and its traditional brick and mud houses replaced by new-builds, despite cries of alarm abroad.

But online social networks are now enabling better organised resistance -- Hua's microblogging feed has almost 15,000 followers.

During the Chinese New Year holidays the former Beijing home of renowned architect couple Liang Sicheng (1901-1972) and Lin Huiyin (1904-1955) -- ironically pioneers of saving Chinese cultural heritage -- was demolished, provoking outrage online.

It is now impossible to approach the site where the residence, which was in theory a protected listed building, stood. The area is controlled by developers, an AFP reporter saw, with security guards preventing access and a fence blocking the view.

"There is nowhere for future generations to remember their work," lamented Yu Wei, a passer-by.

In the city of Chongqing, the former residence of Nationalist China leader Chiang Kai-shek recently fell victim to an official "preventive demolition".

The move triggered widespread criticism -- and the authorities have meekly promised to rebuild it.

  • Make your own breakfast ice cream
    Dzamira Dzafri - ScoopyScoop
    Make your own breakfast ice cream 6 hours ago
    Make your own breakfast ice cream

    Sick of having oatmeal, cereal, pancakes, waffles, toast, milk and nasi lemak for breakfast? Why not start your day fresh and ready with some homemade, specially-for-breakfast ice cream using yoghurt and fruits?Here we would like to share with you the way to make an ice cream healthy enough to enjoy in the morning yet still able to satisfy your sweet tooth. You can choose many different types of yoghurt, but plain yogurt works best for mixing! .

  • Menggayakan skirt kulit
    Dzamira Dzafri - Tupai
    Menggayakan skirt kulit Tue, May 21, 2013 5:22 PM MYT
    Menggayakan skirt kulit

    Jika bijak menyuaipadankan, skirt kulit boleh digunakan bersama pelbagai rupa, dari cara feminine, seksi dan juga profesional.

  • Koleksi fesyen untuk festival muzik
    Ashraf Nasser - Tupai
    Koleksi fesyen untuk festival muzik Tue, May 21, 2013 5:11 PM MYT
    Koleksi fesyen untuk festival muzik

    Jenama fesyen dari United Kingdom, Topshop lancar koleksi pakaian untuk festival musim panas dengan bantuan aktres Kate Bosworth.

  • Danish director Refn splatters Cannes festival with violence
    Belinda Goldsmith - Reuters
    Danish director Refn splatters Cannes festival with violence 16 minutes ago
    Danish director Refn splatters Cannes festival with violence

    By Belinda Goldsmith CANNES (Reuters) - An ultra-violent thriller set in the Bangkok underworld of brothels and fight clubs came under attack at the Cannes film festival on Wednesday for its bloodletting which Danish director Nicolas Winding Refn defended as art. "Only God Forgives" by Refn, who won the best director award at Cannes two years ago, is the story of Julian, an American fugitive played by Canadian Ryan Gosling, who runs a boxing club in the Thai capital as a front for a drug

  • Stephanie Firdaus - Yahoo Newsroom
    14 imunisasi wajib untuk anak Wed, May 15, 2013 1:39 PM MYT

    Imunisasi adalah suatu program bagi memenuhi Konvensyen Hak Anak Pertubuhan Bangsa-Bangsa Bersatu PBB, justeru kerajaan dan ibu bapa harus melakukan yang terbaik demi kesihatan anak-anak, termasuklah dengan memberikan suntikan pelalian atau imunisasi.

Comments on Yahoo! pages are subject to our link to Comments Guidelines. You are responsible for any content that you post. Yahoo! is not responsible or liable in any way for comments posted by its users. Yahoo! does not in any way endorse or support comments made by its users.

  • CANNES: Eva Longoria suffers no pants fashion flash at Cannes Film Fes …
    CANNES: Eva Longoria suffers no pants fashion flash at Cannes Film Fes …

    © Getty - HandbagEva Longoria hit the rainy red carpet at Cannes Film Festival last night, but caught herself in a flesh-flashing fashion mishap while climbing the stairs.Joining fellow L'Oreal face Cheryl Cole at the premiere of Jimmy P. (Psychotherapy Of A Plains Indian), Eva lifted her split-to-the-thigh dress while ascending the steps to the screening, but sadly hitched things a little too high.At the front.No underwear and a hoard of photographers? Yes, we imagine you can guess what

  • Kebaikan epal hijau
    Kebaikan epal hijau

    Buah-buahan sememangnya mempunyai banyak khasiat untuk tubuh badan, namun tahukah anda kebaikan epal hijau?

  • Shila Amzah nasihatkan Afiq Muiz supaya insaf

    Penyanyi Shila Amzah telah menasihati rakannya Afiq Muiz supaya tidak mengabaikan keluarganya.

  • Aiskrim untuk sarapan pagi?
    Aiskrim untuk sarapan pagi?

    Nikmatilah sarapan pagi yang sihat tetapi enak dengan kreatif.

  • Britney shows off toned bod & yoga skills
    Britney shows off toned bod & yoga skills

    Britney Spears – you are looking smoking. Big round of applause. The singer showed off her toned bod in a series of yoga poses wearing skin tight yoga pants and a crop top. The mother-of-two has been known to have a yo-yo battle with her weight but is looking great as she gears up for a new show in Las Vegas and the release of an upcoming album which she's worked on with will.i.am.

  • Melissa McCarthy ‘fires extra’
    Melissa McCarthy ‘fires extra’

    Melissa McCarthy reportedly sacked a female extra getting paid $58 per day to work on Tammy because she disagreed with her parenting.

  • Jolly Good Gudeg, Jolly Good Boss
    Jolly Good Gudeg, Jolly Good Boss

    Indonesia food is not all about spicy offerings - Gudeg, young jackfruit stew, is a very popular rice meal there.